Compass Box The Peat Monster

Score: 69

Compass Box The Peat Monster came into the club tasting with a name that promised chaos—and somehow delivered charm instead. It’s a blended malt built from Islay heavyweights like Caol Ila and Laphroaig, bottled at 46% ABV, and non-chill filtered. On paper, it looked like a peat-head’s dream. But what surprised the room was its restraint. Instead of brute force, it offered balance. The smoke was there, sure, but softened by fruit, spice, and a creamy texture that made it more approachable than expected. Some members joked it was more “Peat Gentleman” than monster, but that didn’t stop it from earning quiet respect. It didn’t win the night, but it held its own—especially with those who appreciate nuance over knockout power.