Tobermory 20 years Sherry Cask

Score: 89

At first, Tobermory 20 comes off floral and perfumed, almost too sweet—but patience pays off. Once oxidation kicks in and the fill level drops, it transforms completely. That classic saline, savory depth emerges, bringing mulled spices, nuts, fruits, and gingerbread, all wrapped in sea spray and brackish water. It takes time to get there, but when it does, it’s seriously rewarding, the clear winner of the night and a whisky worth waiting for. Great dram, great times.