Caol Ila 12 years

Score: 71

Caol Ila 12 Year Old made a strong impression during its club tasting, earning a well-deserved second place and sparking plenty of admiration across the table. Bottled at 43% ABV, it’s often described as an excellent choice for those seeking a smooth and smoky introduction to Islay whiskies. It delivered exactly that, an elegant balance of peat and creamy texture, wrapped in a profile that was both approachable and quietly complex. The smoke was present but never domineering, allowing notes of citrus, sea spray, and subtle spice to shine through. For those who appreciate a lighter touch of Islay’s signature peat, this dram offered a refined gateway, with enough depth to keep seasoned palates intrigued. Its placement in the tasting reflected not just its technical finesse, but its ability to charm a diverse crowd, no theatrics, just quietly confident excellence.