Arran Barrel Reserve

Score: 60

Arran Barrel Reserve entered the tasting as the budget-friendly contender, an approachable single malt aged entirely in bourbon barrels, known for its balance, elegance, and lively character. It’s often a sleeper hit, winning hearts with its affordability and clean, fruit-forward profile. On its own, it’s a solid dram: bright citrus, soft vanilla, gentle spice, and a crisp malt backbone. A balanced, flavorful whisky that’s easy to enjoy and easy to recommend, especially for newcomers or casual sipping. It’s the kind of bottle that quietly earns respect on the shelf. But in this lineup, it was outgunned. Against heavier cask finishes, older age statements, and bolder ABVs, the Barrel Reserve couldn’t quite match the depth or complexity on offer. It held its ground with grace, but ultimately faded into the background. Still, it served its purpose—a reminder that good specs and honest craftsmanship don’t always need fanfare. It may not have climbed the ranks, but it reminded the club that value and quality can coexist, even if they don’t always steal the spotlight.